Can I Negotiate a Building Quote?

You can, and contractors expect questions. The best results come from changing what the job includes, not from pushing on the number alone.

The short answer

Yes. Negotiate the job, and the price follows.

You can negotiate a building quote, and asking questions about it is completely normal. The most productive way to do it is to discuss what the job includes, such as the scope, the materials, the finish and the timing, rather than simply asking for a lower number. When the price comes down, it should be because something about the work has changed, and the revised quote should say what.

A quote is the contractor's price for doing a defined piece of work properly. Squeezing the figure without changing the work usually means something gets taken out later that you would rather have kept. Changing the work openly means you both know exactly what you are getting.

What you can discuss

Six things that can move a price

The scope

Is everything on the quote essential now? Some items can be left out, done later or done yourself, such as decorating afterwards.

Materials and finish

Ask whether a different product or finish would do the job just as well for your purposes, and what the trade-off is.

Timing

Some contractors can be more flexible if you are flexible on the start date. It is fair to ask.

Provisional sums

If part of the price is an allowance rather than a fixed figure, ask how it was worked out. See what is a provisional sum?

Combining work

Having related jobs done in one visit can sometimes share costs such as access equipment.

Anything unclear

Ask what each line covers. Sometimes a quote looks high because it includes things others have left out.

Before you ask

Compare like with like first

Negotiating well starts with understanding why prices differ. Two quotes for what sounds like the same job can include different materials, different access arrangements and different amounts of preparation. Why are building quotes so different? walks through the usual reasons.

If you are holding a lower quote, it is reasonable to mention it, but check first that it covers the same work. How do I compare quotes fairly? has a straightforward method. A contractor is far more likely to respond well to "this one doesn't include scaffolding, can you explain yours?" than to "can you beat this?".

What to leave alone

Savings that tend to cost more later

Good places to look

  • Optional extras and upgrades
  • Finishing work you could do yourself
  • The timing of the start date
  • Items that can wait for a later phase

Better left in the quote

  • Proper access and scaffolding where needed
  • Waste removal
  • Preparation work the contractor says is needed
  • The workmanship warranty
  • Paying cash for a discount

How to ask

A straightforward way to negotiate

  1. Read the whole quote first

    Including the exclusions and the payment terms. Often the question you were going to ask is answered there.

  2. Decide what matters most

    The finish, the start date, the budget ceiling. Knowing your priority tells you where you can be flexible.

  3. Ask open questions

    "What would it cost without the decorating?" gets a more useful answer than "can you do it for less?"

  4. Propose a specific change

    A named change to the scope or specification gives the contractor something concrete to price.

  5. Get the revision in writing

    An updated quote, accepted in writing, before the work starts. What to do before accepting a quote has a checklist.

When the price is the price

A fair price is worth recognising

Sometimes a contractor will not move on price, and that is not necessarily a bad sign. A contractor who has priced carefully, allowing properly for access, materials and time, may have little room without changing the job. A fair price for well-organised work is often better value than a lower figure that leaves things out.

If the main reason you are negotiating is another, lower quote, it is worth reading should I accept the cheapest quote? first. And if a discount is offered for paying in cash, should I pay a builder in cash? explains why a traceable payment is the better choice. The quotes and payments guide covers the rest.

With Mortaro

Ask us, and we put it to your contractor

On a Mortaro quotation, the price is your contractor's, worked out at trade rates after the site visit. If you want to question a line, change the scope or ask whether a different option would cost less, ask us. We put it to your contractor, get the answer and send you any revised figure in writing.

We will not claim to be the cheapest, and we would rather you compared our quotation carefully than chose it on price alone. How quotations work explains what each quotation sets out.

Straight answers

Questions about negotiating

Will asking for a lower price offend the contractor?

Asking politely about scope and options rarely does. Treating the quote as an opening offer to be driven down is more likely to sour things, and you want a good working relationship for the job itself.

Should I get the revised price in writing?

Yes. Any change to the price or the work should be set out in an updated quote before you accept, so there is no doubt later about what was agreed.

Can I negotiate after I've accepted?

You can ask, but once you have accepted, the contractor is entitled to hold to the agreed price for the agreed work. Changes after acceptance are normally about changing the work itself, priced as a variation.

Start here

Tell us about the work you have in mind

We will confirm we cover your postcode, arrange a site visit with a contractor from our network and send you a written quotation. No charge, no obligation.