How to Compare Building Quotes Fairly

A practical method for putting building quotes side by side, so the price you compare is the price of the same job.

The short answer

Compare the job first. Compare the price last.

The fairest way to compare building quotes is to make sure each one describes the same work, on the same basis, before you look at the totals. That means the same scope, comparable materials, the same treatment of scaffolding, waste and VAT, and any uncertain parts separated out. Once that is done, the differences that remain are genuine, and the price becomes a fair comparison.

Most homeowners do it the other way round: they look at three totals, notice one is lower, and then try to work out why. This guide sets out a better order, with a simple comparison sheet you can use on any roofing, rooflight or extension job.

It sits under our wider guide to building quotes and payments, which covers deposits, stage payments and the final balance.

Before the quotes arrive

Give every contractor the same brief

A comparison is only as good as the brief behind it. A few minutes of preparation before the site visits saves a lot of guesswork afterwards.

  1. Write down what you want done

    A few lines is enough: the problem or the goal, the area involved, and anything you already know you want, such as a particular type of rooflight or matching the existing tiles.

  2. Show everyone the same things

    If you point out the damp patch in the back bedroom to one contractor, point it out to all of them. Otherwise one quote allows for it and the others don't.

  3. Mention the same preferences

    Quality of finish, timing, access restrictions and anything about the property that matters to you, such as a conservation area or a shared driveway.

  4. Ask for a written, itemised quote

    Ask each contractor to break the price down into the main parts of the work, rather than giving a single figure. Not every contractor itemises in the same way, but most will give a reasonable breakdown if asked.

  5. Ask the same questions

    Is it a fixed price or an estimate? Does it include VAT? What is the warranty? How long is the price valid? Asking everyone the same questions gives you answers you can compare.

Line them up

Six things to match on every quote

These are the areas where quotes most often differ without saying so. Check each one before you look at the totals.

The scope of work

Is each quote pricing the same job? One may replace the whole roof covering while another repairs the worst section. Both can be sensible, but they are not the same price for the same thing.

Materials

A named product and a phrase like to match existing can cover very different costs. Where a material matters to you, ask each contractor what exactly they have allowed for.

Access and scaffolding

On roofing work, scaffolding can be a large part of the price. Check whether each quote includes it, and for how long. See should scaffolding be on the quote?

Waste and making good

Removing old materials, skip hire and repairing plaster or paintwork afterwards all cost money. Check which quotes include them. See does a quote include waste removal?

VAT

A quote that says plus VAT and one that includes it are not comparable as written. Bring every figure to the same basis first. See VAT on building work.

Timing and warranty

When can they start, how long will it take, and how long is their workmanship warranty? These affect the value of a quote even when they don't change the price.

A simple tool

Build a comparison sheet

The easiest way to compare quotes is a simple grid. On paper or in a spreadsheet, list the contractors across the top and the headings down the side: scope, materials, scaffolding, waste, making good, provisional sums, VAT, total, start date, duration, warranty and validity.

Then fill in each box from the quote itself. Where the quote says nothing, write not stated rather than assuming. It is surprising how quickly the gaps show up. A quote that looked cheapest often turns out to have three not stated boxes that the others filled in.

Next, send each contractor a short message about their gaps. Your quote doesn't mention scaffolding; is it included? Keep the replies. A written answer to a written question is worth more than a remembered conversation, and it becomes part of what you agreed if you go ahead.

Finally, adjust the totals so they are on the same basis. If one quote leaves out waste removal, ask for a price for it and add it. If one is ex-VAT, add the VAT. Now the bottom row of your sheet is a fair comparison.

If you need a reminder of what each quote should contain in the first place, our guide to what a building quote should include lists every element and what it should say.

Reading the differences

Normal differences, and ones worth a question

Some variation between quotes is simply how the trade works. Some is a sign that the quotes are not describing the same job.

Usually normal

  • Different overheads and supplier prices
  • A contractor with a busy diary pricing higher
  • Different, equally sound methods for the same result
  • A slightly different start date or duration
  • Quotes laid out in different formats
  • Different warranty lengths from different firms

Worth asking about

  • One quote much lower than the others
  • A single total with no breakdown at all
  • Scaffolding, waste or VAT not mentioned
  • Large provisional sums with no explanation
  • Materials described only vaguely
  • No clear statement of what is excluded

Outliers

When one price is far lower, or far higher

A quote well below the rest is not automatically a bad sign. Some contractors are efficient, have low overheads, or have a gap in their diary they want to fill. But a large gap usually has a reason, and it is worth knowing what it is before you accept.

The most common reasons are a narrower scope, cheaper materials, something left out entirely, or an estimate presented as if it were a firm price. Each of these tends to reappear later: as an extra, as a shorter-lived result or as a bill that grows. Our guide on why the cheapest quote can cost more explains how that happens.

A quote well above the rest also deserves a question. It may include things the others have missed, allow for a better-quality product, or reflect a contractor who has spotted a problem the others didn't. Ask them to walk you through it. Sometimes the highest quote turns out to be the only one that priced the whole job.

Watch out for uncertain items. If one quote includes a large provisional sum and another doesn't mention the same issue, the second quote may simply not have allowed for it. Provisional sums, explained covers how to compare them.

And check what kind of figure you have. A fixed-price quote and an estimate are not comparable in the same way; the estimate can move. If you are not sure which you are holding, see estimate vs quote.

Questions are part of the process

Asking a contractor to explain their quote is normal, and a good contractor expects it. Keep questions specific and in writing where you can. If you would like to discuss the price itself, our answer on negotiating a building quote covers how to do it fairly.

Beyond the price

Value is about who does the work, too

Once the quotes are on the same basis, price is one factor among several. The contractor's reviews and references, their insurance, their experience with this kind of job and how clearly they have communicated so far all matter, and none of them show up in the total.

How a contractor handles the quoting stage is often a fair preview of how they will handle the job. Did they turn up when they said they would? Did the quote arrive when promised? Did they answer your questions clearly? A slightly dearer quote from someone who has been organised and straightforward throughout can be better value than a cheaper one from someone who has been hard to pin down.

It also helps to decide in advance how many quotes you need. Too few and you have little to compare; too many and the process becomes hard to manage. Our guide on how many quotes to get goes through the trade-offs.

Two more things are easy to overlook. The first is the warranty. Contractors set their own workmanship warranty terms, so they can differ from quote to quote in length, in what they cover and in when they start. A warranty that is written into the quote is worth more than one mentioned in passing on site, and a longer warranty on a larger job can justify a somewhat higher price.

The second is timing. A quote that can start next week and one that can start in three months are not quite the same offer, particularly if the job is a leak that needs attention. Equally, a very early start date on a large job is worth a question about how the contractor is fitting it in. And check how long each quote is valid for. If you need longer to decide, ask before the date passes rather than after, because once a quote has expired the contractor may revise the price.

Making the decision

Choosing between quotes, in order

  1. Rule out any that are unclear

    If a contractor won't put the price in writing or won't answer reasonable questions about it, it is hard to compare them fairly with anyone.

  2. Adjust the rest to the same basis

    Same scope, same inclusions, same VAT treatment. Ask for prices for anything missing.

  3. Compare the adjusted totals

    Now the differences are real, and you can weigh them properly.

  4. Weigh the things price doesn't show

    Warranty, start date, reviews and references, and how well each contractor has communicated.

  5. Confirm the details before you accept

    Get any changes or clarifications written into the quote, or confirmed by email, before you say yes.

Daylight falling through a rooflight into a quiet room.

Comparing our quotation

How a Mortaro quotation lines up

If you are comparing a Mortaro quotation with others, the same method applies. Our quotations are prepared from your contractor's trade-rate pricing after the site visit, set out on a consistent template, and name your appointed main contractor, so you know exactly who will be doing the work.

They are free, carry no obligation and are valid for 30 days, which gives you time to compare properly and ask us anything. If something isn't clear, we get the answer from your contractor. We don't claim to be the cheapest: the aim is a price comparable to going direct, with the coordination included. How quotations work explains the process.

Straight answers

Questions about comparing quotes

What is the most important thing to compare?

The scope of work. If the quotes aren't describing the same job, nothing else about them can be compared fairly. Check scope first, then materials, inclusions and VAT, and the price last.

What if a contractor won't itemise their quote?

Ask what the main parts of the price are, even roughly. If they won't say at all, you can still compare, but you will need more questions to be sure the quotes cover the same work.

Should I tell contractors what the other quotes said?

You don't have to. It is fair to ask a contractor whether they have allowed for something another quote includes, without sharing prices.

Is a longer warranty worth paying more for?

It can be, particularly on larger work. Check how long the warranty lasts, what it covers and who gives it, and weigh it alongside price rather than on its own.

Start here

Tell us about the work you have in mind

We will confirm we cover your postcode, arrange a site visit with a contractor from our network and send you a written quotation. No charge, no obligation.