Checkatrade vs MyBuilder vs Rated People: A Contractor’s Comparison
Three of the UK's best-known platforms for trades, compared on how they charge, how enquiries reach you and which kind of firm each tends to suit.
The comparison
Checkatrade charges for a listing; MyBuilder and Rated People charge per lead. Which suits you depends on how you win work, not which name is biggest.
On published 2026 pricing, Checkatrade membership costs £600 to £1,200 a year, while MyBuilder and Rated People charge £15 to £60 per lead. That difference in model matters more than the headline figures. One asks you to commit up front and wait for customers to contact you. The other two let you choose which jobs to pay for, one enquiry at a time.
All three are established UK businesses, and plenty of contractors use each of them successfully. Plenty of others have tried one and left. The difference usually comes down to trade, area, how quickly the firm can respond and how well it quotes.
This guide sets out how each platform charges, how enquiries reach you, and the questions worth answering before you sign up to any of them. Pricing and terms change, so check each platform's current terms before relying on anything here.
Published prices
What each platform charges contractors
Published 2026 pricing. MyBuilder and Rated People are grouped because the published range covers both.
Platform pricing as published by Trades Grow, One Base Media, Sleepless Tradesman and SwiftLead, 2026. Rates change, so check current pricing before relying on these figures. Google Ads figures as published by PositionWorks (2025 UK home services benchmarks, roofing) and Aimpro Digital (2026). Click prices vary by area, service and how well the account is run.
How each one works
Three platforms, two models
A summary of how each platform's model works for a contractor, based on published pricing and widely reported features.
Checkatrade: a membership directory
You pay a membership fee to be listed, and homeowners search the directory and contact you through your profile. Customer reviews sit on your listing and carry a lot of weight. Checkatrade carries out its own checks before listing members; what those checks cover is set out in its current terms. Your cost is fixed however many enquiries arrive.
MyBuilder: pay per lead
Homeowners post a job describing the work, and tradespeople who want it register their interest. You pay per lead rather than for a listing, so you only spend on jobs you choose to pursue. Exactly when a charge applies is set out in MyBuilder's current terms, and it is worth reading before you start.
Rated People: pay per lead
Homeowners describe the job and tradespeople pay to take up the leads they want. Like MyBuilder, the cost follows the leads you choose. Plans and pricing options change over time, so check which applies to your trade and area when you join.
The real difference
A listing you pay for vs leads you pay for
Most of the practical difference between the three comes from the model, not the brand.
Membership (Checkatrade)
- Fixed cost, known in advance
- Paid before any enquiry arrives
- Customers contact you directly
- Reviews on your profile drive enquiries
- Quiet months cost the same as busy ones
- Suits firms with steady capacity and strong reviews
Pay per lead (MyBuilder, Rated People)
- Cost follows the leads you take up
- You choose which jobs to pay for
- The same job is commonly open to several trades
- Speed of response matters a great deal
- Easy to scale up or down month to month
- Suits firms that can reply and quote quickly
In more detail
What each model means for your week
On a membership directory, the work comes to you. A homeowner looks at listings in their area, reads reviews and gets in touch. That can produce good-quality enquiries, because the customer has chosen you rather than been sent to you. It also means your volume depends on things you only partly control: how many other firms in your trade are listed nearby, how many reviews you have, and how prominent your listing is. The membership is paid either way. Our assessment of whether Checkatrade is worth it for tradesmen works through that trade-off.
On a pay-per-lead platform, you go to the work. You see jobs posted in your area, decide which ones you want, and pay to take them up. That gives you control over spend, which suits firms that are busy some months and quiet in others. The model also means the same job is commonly open to more than one tradesperson, so the customer may hear from several firms. Being first to reply with something useful counts for a lot. Our guide on whether MyBuilder is worth it covers how to test a per-lead platform properly.
Neither model does the selling for you. On all three platforms you still answer the enquiry, book the visit, write the quote, follow it up and collect payment. The platform's job is to connect you with a customer. Everything after that is yours, and it is where most of the difference in results between contractors comes from.
Platform pricing as published by Trades Grow, One Base Media, Sleepless Tradesman and SwiftLead, 2026. Rates change, so check current pricing before relying on these figures.
Shared enquiries
Why the same job often reaches several trades
On pay-per-lead platforms, it is commonly reported that one homeowner's job can be taken up by several tradespeople. That is how the model works rather than a fault in it: the customer gets a choice, and the platform earns from each trade who takes the lead up.
For you, it means each lead is a competition. The customer may compare several prices, and the decision often comes down to who replied first, who explained the job clearly, and whose quote looked most professional. Price matters, but it is rarely the only factor. Our answer on why leads go to multiple traders explains the economics.
On a directory the picture is different but not exclusive either. A homeowner browsing listings can contact as many firms as they like, and many will contact more than one.
Choosing
How to decide which, if any, suits you
Work through these in order. The answers usually point clearly one way.
Be honest about your response time
If you can't reply to an enquiry within a few hours during the working day, a pay-per-lead model will be harder work, because other trades will get there first. A directory, where the customer has already chosen you, is more forgiving.
Look at your cash flow
A membership is a fixed cost, generally paid up front. Per-lead spend follows your activity. If a large upfront payment would stretch you, per-lead is easier to start with and easier to stop.
Check your reviews
A directory listing with few or no reviews tends to struggle against established profiles. If you have a strong review record, a listing can make better use of it.
Think about your job size
On higher-value work, a higher lead price can still leave a healthy margin. On small jobs, a lead fee can eat most of the profit before you've quoted.
Test one at a time
Run one platform for a set period, track every lead and every win, and work out your cost per job won. Then try another if you want to compare. Running several at once makes it hard to tell which is working.
Read the terms first
Minimum terms, cancellation, how invalid leads are handled and what is included in each plan all differ. Pricing and terms change; check the platform's current terms before you commit.
Before you sign
Six questions to ask any platform
What exactly do I pay for?
A listing, a lead, a connection or a bundle. Get the unit clear before you compare prices.
Is there a minimum term?
Annual commitments are common on memberships. Know how and when you can leave.
How are bad leads handled?
Wrong numbers, duplicate jobs and out-of-area enquiries happen. Ask what the process is and whether credits are given.
How many trades see each job?
Ask directly. The answer tells you how competitive each enquiry will be.
What does my listing show?
Reviews, checks, photos and profile details all affect whether a customer picks you.
How will I measure it?
Decide before you start how you'll track cost per job won. Without that, you can't tell if it is working.
Whichever you choose
Getting more from the leads you pay for
The platform brings you to the customer. What happens next decides whether the spend pays off, and it is the same on all three.
Reply the same day, ideally within a couple of hours, and say something useful: when you could visit, what you'd need to see, roughly how the job would be approached. Book the visit while the customer is still engaged. After the visit, send a clear written quote that sets out the scope, the price, what is included and what isn't, and when you could start. Then follow it up a few days later, politely, because customers who go quiet have often simply not got round to deciding.
None of that is complicated, but it is hard to do from a roof or halfway through a kitchen fit. Most contractors who struggle on lead platforms aren't losing on workmanship. They're losing on time. Our guide on how to quote faster and win more covers practical ways to tighten each step.
Another option
Where a contractor network sits alongside these
All three platforms connect you with a customer and leave the rest to you. A contractor network works differently. Mortaro generates the enquiries itself and appoints one contractor to each one, so the enquiry isn't open to other firms. Is the work exclusive? covers that directly.
There is no membership and no charge per lead. You survey the job and price it at trade rate; Mortaro prepares the quotation with its fee added on top, follows it up, and administers the deposit and balance to you without unnecessary delay. You are paid your rate in full.
The trade-offs are real. The customer receives the quotation under the Mortaro template, the network has standards on response times, quoting and site visits, and the amount of work depends on your area, your trade and your track record. How contractor networks work explains the full arrangement, and our guide to getting more work sets it alongside every other route.
No platform is right for every firm. The one that suits you is the one with a cost per job won you are comfortable with, after your time is counted. The true cost per job won shows how to work it out, and pay-per-lead vs subscription goes deeper on the two models.
Straight answers
Comparing the three platforms
Which is cheapest: Checkatrade, MyBuilder or Rated People?
It depends on how many leads you take up. On published 2026 pricing, Checkatrade is £600 to £1,200 a year and MyBuilder and Rated People are £15 to £60 per lead. A firm taking a handful of leads a month may spend less per lead; a firm taking many may spend more. See how much Checkatrade costs for the membership detail.
Can I use more than one?
Yes, and many contractors do. It is easier to judge each one if you start them at different times and track results separately.
Which gets the best-quality leads?
There is no reliable published answer. Quality varies by trade and area, and much of what decides whether a lead converts is how quickly and how well you respond.
How does Bark compare?
Bark charges per connection, published at £6 to £30 in 2026, and covers a wide range of services beyond the building trades. Our review of Bark for tradespeople covers it in detail.
For contractors
Tell us about your business
Your trade, the areas you cover and the size of work you take on. A person reads every enquiry, and if it looks like a fit we will send you the full application.